Top Orthopedic Surgeons in New York

New York Rankings 334 surgeons • 23,087 procedures Current Medicare Data

Rankings reflect Medicare procedure volume, one factor among many. Volume does not measure quality of care.

Discover New York's leading orthopedic surgeons ranked by verified Medicare procedure volume. Our comprehensive analysis covers 334 specialists across hip, knee, and shoulder replacement procedures.

Orthopedic surgeon rankings map

Find Surgeons by City in New York

Top cities by number of orthopedic surgeons

New York Rankings

334 surgeons • All procedures

Current Medicare data
Joint replacement recovery essentials 7-piece recovery essentials kit. Prepare before surgery day.
1

Michael E Ciminiello, MD

Riverhead, NY
389 verified Medicare cases Hip 141 · Knee 248
2

Brian P Chalmers, M.D.

New York, NY
343 verified Medicare cases Hip 146 · Knee 197
3

Jason Blevins, MD

New York, NY
322 verified Medicare cases Hip 167 · Knee 155
4

Eytan M Debbi, MD PHD

New York, NY
322 verified Medicare cases Hip 124 · Knee 198
5

Amar S Ranawat, M.D.

New York, NY
318 verified Medicare cases Hip 134 · Knee 184
6

James Nicholson, M.D.

East Setauket, NY
308 verified Medicare cases Hip 120 · Knee 188
7

Michael P Nett, M.D.

Bay Shore, NY
303 verified Medicare cases Hip 77 · Knee 226
8

Ayal Segal, MD

Glen Cove, NY
293 verified Medicare cases Hip 122 · Knee 171
9
276 verified Medicare cases Hip 94 · Knee 182
10

Jonathan R Danoff, M.D.

Great Neck, NY
252 verified Medicare cases Hip 130 · Knee 122
11

Scott W Alpert, MD

Huntington Station, NY
232 verified Medicare cases Hip 90 · Knee 116 · Shoulder 26
12
229 verified Medicare cases Hip 118 · Knee 111
13

Steven B Zelicof, M.D.

Harrison, NY
229 verified Medicare cases Hip 82 · Knee 147
14

Alberto Carli, M.D.

New York, NY
225 verified Medicare cases Hip 70 · Knee 155
15
222 verified Medicare cases Hip 93 · Knee 118 · Shoulder 11
16

Cynthia Kahlenberg

New York, NY
217 verified Medicare cases Hip 107 · Knee 110
17

Herbert J Cooper, MD

New York, NY
216 verified Medicare cases Hip 129 · Knee 87
18

Andrew B Wickline, MD

New Hartford, NY
211 verified Medicare cases Hip 74 · Knee 137
19

John M Hardcastle, M.D.

Middletown, NY
207 verified Medicare cases Hip 81 · Knee 126
20

Douglas M Petraco, MD

East Setauket, NY
205 verified Medicare cases Hip 83 · Knee 122
21

Jeffrey Geller, M.D.

New York, NY
194 verified Medicare cases Hip 92 · Knee 102
22
191 verified Medicare cases Hip 104 · Knee 87
23

James A Germano, M.D.

Rockville Centre, NY
185 verified Medicare cases Hip 68 · Knee 117
24

Keith R Reinhardt, M.D.

Bay Shore, NY
184 verified Medicare cases Hip 93 · Knee 91
25

Kevin Cassidy, M.D.

Great Neck, NY
184 verified Medicare cases Hip 68 · Knee 116

Showing 25 of 334

Important Disclaimer

Rankings are based solely on Medicare procedure volume and do not reflect quality of care, patient outcomes, or procedures covered by private insurance. This data represents approximately 33–37% of all procedures performed. Always consult with healthcare providers to make informed decisions about your care.