OrthoProcedures

Top Knee Replacement Surgeons in Columbus

Columbus Rankings 12 surgeons • 469 verified Medicare procedures Public CMS Medicare data

Rankings reflect Medicare procedure volume, one factor among many. Volume does not measure quality of care.

Discover Columbus's leading knee replacement surgeons ranked by verified Medicare procedure volume. Our comprehensive analysis covers 12 specialists performing knee replacement procedures in Columbus, Indiana.

Other Procedures in Columbus

Hip Replacement Columbus Knee Replacement Columbus Shoulder Replacement Columbus
All Indiana Surgeons

Other Indiana Cities

Indianapolis
12
Surgeons
469
Verified Medicare procedures
60
Most by one surgeon
39
Average per surgeon
Knee replacement recovery kit Ice machines, mobility aids, bathroom safety, all under $50
1

Brandon R Hood, M.D.

Bloomington, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 60 verified Medicare cases
2

Joshua L Carter, M.D.

Indianapolis, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 58 verified Medicare cases
3

Eric A Monesmith, M.D.

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 55 verified Medicare cases
4

Colin T Penrose, M.D.

Indianapolis, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 54 verified Medicare cases
5

Timothy J Williams, M.D.

Indianapolis, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 51 verified Medicare cases
6

Wesley G Lackey, M.D.

Indianapolis, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 48 verified Medicare cases
7

Benjamin J Justice, M.D.

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 45 verified Medicare cases
8

Matthew E Lovell, M.D.

Columbus, IN
Knee Replacement: 29 verified Medicare cases
9

Eric P Tannenbaum, M.D.

Columbus, IN
Knee Replacement: 20 verified Medicare cases
10

Douglas J Federle, M.D.

Columbus, IN
Knee Replacement: 20 verified Medicare cases
11

Mitchell W Beckert, M.D.

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Columbus Regional Hospital
Knee Replacement: 15 verified Medicare cases
12

Cary M Guse, M.D.

Columbus, IN
Knee Replacement: 14 verified Medicare cases

Knee Replacement in Columbus: the local picture

Public CMS Medicare data verifies 469 knee replacement procedures performed by the 12 surgeons listed on this page, all serving the Columbus area. Hospital affiliations among these surgeons most often include Columbus Regional Hospital.

Compare more of Indiana: All Indiana surgeons Surgeons in Indianapolis Surgeons in Fort Wayne Surgeons in South Bend

Important Disclaimer

Rankings show Medicare procedure volume only, not quality of care or patient outcomes. Verify a surgeon's credentials with your state medical board, and talk with your own healthcare provider.

This data covers approximately 23% to 28% of all knee replacement procedures performed nationwide in 2024 (how this share is derived).

Frequently Asked Questions About Knee Replacement in Columbus

How do I choose the best knee replacement surgeon in Columbus?
Look for surgeons with high Medicare procedure volumes (200+ knee replacements annually), board certification in orthopedic surgery, experience with both total and partial knee replacement, and affiliations with quality hospitals. Our Columbus rankings help you compare surgeons based on Medicare volume data.
What is the average cost of knee replacement in Columbus, Indiana?
Medicare covers 80% of knee replacement costs after deductible. Out-of-pocket costs typically range from $1,500-$4,000 depending on the facility, surgeon, and your Medicare plan. Columbus surgeons who accept Medicare assignment help keep costs predictable.
How long does knee replacement recovery take?
Most patients begin walking with assistance the same day or day after surgery. Return to normal activities takes 6-12 weeks for most people. Physical therapy typically starts immediately and continues for 8-12 weeks. Columbus surgeons often use rapid recovery protocols to speed healing.
What's the difference between total and partial knee replacement?
Total knee replacement replaces the entire knee joint surface, while partial (unicompartmental) knee replacement only replaces the damaged portion. Partial knee replacement has faster recovery but requires very specific damage patterns. Columbus surgeons can evaluate which approach is best for your condition.
Does Medicare cover knee replacement surgery in Columbus?
Yes, Medicare covers medically necessary knee replacement surgery, including traditional and robotic-assisted procedures. Coverage includes surgery, hospital stay, anesthesia, physical therapy, and durable medical equipment. You pay 20% coinsurance after your Part B deductible. All Columbus ranked surgeons accept Medicare.

Other Procedures in Columbus

Indiana Resources

Learn More