OrthoProcedures

Top Shoulder Replacement Surgeons in Indianapolis

Indianapolis Rankings 16 surgeons • 465 verified Medicare procedures Public CMS Medicare data

Rankings reflect Medicare procedure volume, one factor among many. Volume does not measure quality of care.

Discover Indianapolis's leading shoulder replacement surgeons ranked by verified Medicare procedure volume. Our comprehensive analysis covers 16 specialists performing shoulder replacement procedures in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Other Procedures in Indianapolis

Hip Replacement Indianapolis Knee Replacement Indianapolis Shoulder Replacement Indianapolis
All Indiana Surgeons
16
Surgeons
465
Verified Medicare procedures
83
Most by one surgeon
29
Average per surgeon
Shoulder replacement recovery kit Slings, cold therapy, and adaptive clothing for recovery
1

Brian L Badman, MD

Fishers, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 83 verified Medicare cases
2

Michael J Bender, M.D.

Carmel, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 64 verified Medicare cases
3

Timothy M Steiner, MD

Bloomington, IN
Also practices here via Indiana University Health
Shoulder Replacement: 51 verified Medicare cases
4

Mark T Dillon, MD

Indianapolis, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 38 verified Medicare cases
5

Stephen P Jacobsen, MD

Carmel, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 32 verified Medicare cases
6

Dale S Snead, MD

Carmel, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 27 verified Medicare cases
7

Jeffery J Soldatis, MD

Carmel, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 22 verified Medicare cases
8

David M Foulk, MD

Indianapolis, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 20 verified Medicare cases
9

Christopher A Defalco, M.D.

Indianapolis, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 19 verified Medicare cases
10

Matthew R Lavery, MD

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Orthoindy Hospital
Shoulder Replacement: 17 verified Medicare cases
11

Ryan A Nixon, M.D.

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Franciscan Health Indianapolis
Shoulder Replacement: 17 verified Medicare cases
12

Ripley W Worman, MD

Indianapolis, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 16 verified Medicare cases
13

Kevin W Condict, MD

Carmel, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 16 verified Medicare cases
14

Gregory T Reveal, MD

Indianapolis, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 16 verified Medicare cases
15

Matthew R Walker, MD

Greenwood, IN
Also practices here via Orthoindy Hospital
Shoulder Replacement: 15 verified Medicare cases
16

Aaron M Baessler, MD

Fishers, IN
Shoulder Replacement: 12 verified Medicare cases

Shoulder Replacement in Indianapolis: the local picture

Public CMS Medicare data verifies 465 shoulder replacement procedures performed by the 16 surgeons listed on this page, all serving the Indianapolis area. Hospital affiliations among these surgeons most often include Orthoindy Hospital, Franciscan Health Orthopedic Hospital Carmel, and Indiana University Health.

Compare more of Indiana: All Indiana surgeons Surgeons in Fort Wayne Surgeons in South Bend Surgeons in Carmel

Important Disclaimer

Rankings are based solely on Medicare procedure volume and do not reflect quality of care, patient outcomes, or procedures covered by private insurance. This data represents approximately 33–37% of all procedures performed. Always consult with healthcare providers to make informed decisions about your care.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shoulder Replacement in Indianapolis

How do I choose the best shoulder replacement surgeon in Indianapolis?
Look for surgeons who specialize in shoulder surgery with high procedure volumes (50+ shoulder replacements annually), board certification, fellowship training in shoulder and elbow surgery, and experience with reverse shoulder replacement. Indianapolis has specialized shoulder surgeons ranked by Medicare volume.
What is the average cost of shoulder replacement in Indianapolis, Indiana?
Medicare covers 80% of shoulder replacement costs after your deductible. Typical out-of-pocket costs range from $1,500-$4,500 depending on procedure complexity and facility. Indianapolis surgeons who participate in Medicare help control costs through standard fee schedules.
How long is recovery after shoulder replacement?
Initial recovery takes 6-8 weeks with arm support in a sling. Full recovery including strength and range of motion takes 6-12 months. Physical therapy is crucial and typically continues for 3-6 months. Indianapolis surgeons provide comprehensive recovery protocols for optimal outcomes.
What's the difference between regular and reverse shoulder replacement?
Regular (anatomic) shoulder replacement maintains natural joint structure. Reverse shoulder replacement switches the ball and socket positions, used for patients with rotator cuff damage. Indianapolis surgeons evaluate which type is appropriate based on your specific shoulder condition and rotator cuff integrity.
Does Medicare cover shoulder replacement in Indianapolis?
Yes, Medicare covers both anatomic and reverse shoulder replacement when medically necessary. Coverage includes surgery, hospital care, anesthesia, physical therapy, and medical equipment. You pay 20% coinsurance after meeting your Part B deductible. Indianapolis ranked surgeons accept Medicare assignment.

Other Procedures in Indianapolis

Indiana Resources

Learn More